by Gareth Mann Sitz
My maternal instinct, intense since I first started babysitting when I was eleven, was thwarted when my husband and I tried to start a family after four years of marriage. Eight years later, after innumerable frustrating tests, we adopted a son, and I settled into the joy of nurturing. I cannot begin to describe the pain and sense of longing I felt in being childless. Month after month, test after test, I had become more and more discouraged. Paul was almost forty years old, and adoption agencies didn’t want to place a child in a home where one of the parents was over forty. When I got that life-changing phone call telling me a little boy had been born, our paperwork had been completed for only two weeks. We had expected to wait years, yet miraculously, our name had moved up the list because no one wanted a Puerto Rican baby. How sorry those couples would have been if they had seen our precious blond-haired blue-eyed son!
David was born in August of 1979, and we brought him home straight from the hospital, at five days old. Upon seeing my husband at the hospital, the nurse had exclaimed, “Look at the coloring on that father!.” And it was true; David’s fuzzy reddish blond hair and complexion echoed my husband’s, and from the beginning no one doubted that he was our biological son. We had no need for a child who looked like us; David was half-Puerto Rican, and we fully expected a brown-skinned black haired baby. Yet he was blond and blue-eyed like virtually everyone in my husband’s family.
As he grew, David developed a head of phenomenal blond curls. With his dimpled face, long eyelashes, and muscular strong body, he was an adorable child, engendering compliments wherever we went.. He was an energetic and playful toddler, and from his earliest social interactions, he had an outgoing and forceful personality.
When David was an infant, I took him everywhere. I remember directing a production of Godspell when he was two months old, carrying him around on my shoulder during rehearsals. At church, he was routinely passed around from person to person, everyone thrilled at the new addition to our family. Our young female pastor would visit us during breaks from her duties, taking him for a stroller ride in the park. Several of our friends had older children, and David was cuddled and fussed over by several little girls between the ages of seven and twelve. Across the street, a family of five girls, ages ten through sixteen, quickly became fixtures in David’s life. Because David was a bottle-fed baby, we were able to leave him with a trusted babysitter from an early age, and we frequently went out to dinner or to the theatre on the weekends.
Making friends came easily to David, and his social skills helped him sail through childhood with a swarm of little boys who sought his company. He was a natural leader when it came to creative play and an excellent team player on the soccer field. Like me, connecting with others was always important to him. He wasn’t at all like his quiet and intellectual father, but a boisterous and physical child, always on the move. He climbed to the top of the huge slide in Lord’s Park when he was eighteen months old, mastered his big wheel when he was two, and learned to ride a bike without training wheels when he was four. His doting father was thrilled with our son’s athletic prowess and daredevil personality, encouraging him every step of the way. When I would cringe seeing my little one roar down the hill on his big wheel and later my teenager handling a skateboard and snowboard with abandon, my husband would assure me that David knew what he was doing.
Gifted with excellent gross motor skills, David was different from both his father and me. Paul had been a fair athlete, but I had been a total klutz, the last one chosen for any team. We took pride in David’s skill in soccer and marveled at his early ability to handle anything with wheels. Even today, David readily acknowledges that he was “born to drive,” and he delights in driving a flat bed tow truck with ease.
Adopting David changed my world. I took a year off from my whirlwind life of teaching and nonstop theatrical activity, settling happily into maternal bliss. Friends noticed immediately my incessant joy, and I knew intuitively that my body chemistry had changed. My husband marveled at my natural mothering skills, pleasantly surprised at the ease with which I adjusted to taking care of a newborn.
Nine months after David’s adoption. after eight years of infertility, when I was thirty three years old, I became pregnant. It was a rough pregnancy, with me on bed rest for the first four months due to spotting. I refused to take any medication designed to help me keep the baby, knowing in my heart that I would have a healthy baby if that were my destiny. When Kyra was born in February of 1981, a full-term baby weighing only four pounds fourteen ounces, I was ecstatic. The first thing my husband said when he saw her was, “She has your chin!” Looking back, that was my first indication that it would be different having a biological child.
From the beginning, people would look at Kiki and call her my “clone.” With her dark eyes and facial structure, there was no doubt that I was her mother. Because she was so tiny, I nursed her on demand. For the first two months, we bonded every two hours in my rocking chair. She was two and a half before she stopped nursing, already speaking full sentences and potty trained. David was still on the bottle at eighteen months when his sister was born, and I would blissfully sit on the couch with my newborn at my breast and my precious son cuddled next to me happily drinking his bottle.
Because my daughter needed so much physical contact with me from the outset, my husband took over and became the primary parent for my son whenever he was home. David was his father’s constant companion, and to this day, he prefers his father to me, often calling on the phone with his very first sentence being,”Is dad around?”
As my daughter grew, our attachment became more and more intense. I still adored my adorable curly-headed son, but I would be lying if I said it didn’t feel different having a daughter, especially one who shared my genetic traits. I know that most women long for a daughter just as most men desire at least one son. Yet, I was blessed with a little girl who fulfilled all my maternal fantasies. She was loquacious and inquisitive, loving dolls and books and pretty clothes. I was her parent of choice, and although she loved her father, she was definitely a “mama’s girl.” Her talents in acting and writing were evident at an early age, and she attended every session of the children’s theatre classes I taught at Elgin Community College. At nine, she had her first leading role in a play; at eleven, she won a writing award; she showed an early aptitude for mimicry and foreign languages. And, because my mother had been so close to me, I naturally reveled in our emotional intimacy.
David and Kiki adored one another. They helped me bake cookies and danced together around the living room. Because Kiki was an early talker, they were able to communicate well before she was eighteen months, and I spent many happy hours enjoying their creative play. Childhood photos attest to the depth of their loving relationship. As Kiki was a blond little girl, no one doubted that they were natural siblings. Though David was aware he was adopted, he knew how much he was cherished and a part of our family. I thought I was the luckiest woman in the world, with two such wonderful children.
Four years later, to our total surprise, we were blessed with another pregnancy, and our youngest son was born in 1985. Kiki had actually requested a new baby in the family the year before. When I told her that babies were hard to come by in our family, my three year old daughter looked at me with conviction and said, “Well, I’m going to pray.” From the time I knew of my pregnancy, Kiki was convinced that she was responsible for my conception. Her total joy is reflected in the picture she chose for her facebook profile, of the two of us wearing mother-daughter dresses I had made from a print with tiny strawberries on a navy background. In the photo, I am serene and eight months pregnant, and my little daughter is animated and gleeful.
When James, whom we called “Jamie,” was born, David was six and Kyra was four. From the beginning, both siblings doted on him. David was thrilled to have a brother, and Kiki thought of Jamie as HER baby because she had prayed for him. They fussed over him and cuddled him, taking turns holding him and handing me diapers. My husband and I, at thirty-eight and forty-seven, had three children, gifts beyond our wildest imagination. Each one of our children was an unexpected miracle.
Raising two biological children with our first child created a fertile ground for the study of heredity and environment. When Jamie, like his sister, looked like me and exhibited obvious genetic characteristics in aptitudes and intelligence to both my husband and myself, I know that David sometimes felt as though he didn’t belong. No matter how much love we showered on him, no matter how much attention we gave him, David grew up feeling different from the rest of our family.
We did not seek to have children to produce images of ourselves. We merely longed for the joy of parenthood, for the opportunity to share our love and create a family.
I truly believe David was destined to be my son, and without him, I would not have the rest of my family. I have compassion for his struggles with his identity growing up with two biological siblings, but I am confident that we provided an environment in which he could thrive. I regret that we bent over backwards to prove our love, often spoiling him and being lax with discipline, but overall, we did our best.
Only now, when David witnesses our total devotion to his three children, is he finally convinced how much we have always treasured him. Watching him delight in his progeny is a source of constant pleasure. He has the biological connection he has always missed, and we have amazing grandchildren to love. Never for a moment do I think about blood ties, only of how very fortunate I am to have these children in my life.
Yes, my home has been a laboratory for the study of genetics and environment. How grateful I am to have been part of this experiment!
.